If you’ve ever tasted a key lime pie that made you close your eyes and say, “this is the real deal,” then you’ve probably had the joy of experiencing Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie. This isn’t just another dessert — it’s a tradition wrapped in a flaky crust, zesty lime filling, and a dollop of whipped cream that feels like a warm hug from the Florida Keys themselves. For over two decades, Steve, Victoria, and their son Derek have poured their hearts into crafting a pie that’s more than just sweet — it’s a story, a legacy, and a love letter to the original flavor of the Keys.

It all started with Steve, a man who believed that the only way to make a great key lime pie was to make it the way it was always made — with care, quality ingredients, and a little bit of soul. Whether you’re a local Brooklynite or a pie lover from across the country, Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie is a taste you won’t soon forget. And if you’ve ever found yourself wondering where to find the best key lime pie in the city, or why this particular pie has earned such a loyal following, you’re in the right place.

So, whether you're planning a weekend trip to Red Hook, thinking about shipping a pie to a friend, or just curious about the magic behind the meringue, stick around. We’re diving into everything that makes Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie not just a dessert, but a destination in itself. And if you’re asking yourself, “what’s the big deal about key lime pie anyway?” — well, you might be surprised how much joy can come from one perfect slice.

• High Protein Slow Cooker Recipes

Table of Contents

1. About Steve and His Team
2. The Story Behind the Pie
3. Why It’s Called “Authentic”
4. Where to Buy Steve’s Pies
5. How to Order and Ship a Pie
6. Steve’s Pie vs. The Rest
7. FAQ Section

About Steve and His Team

Steve Tarpin is more than just a baker — he’s a craftsman. With over 23 years of experience perfecting the art of key lime pie, Steve’s dedication to quality and tradition is what sets his pies apart. Alongside his wife Victoria and their son Derek, the Tarpin family has made Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie a Brooklyn staple. Derek might not be thrilled about some of the old photos floating around, but he’s clearly proud of what his parents have built — and the fact that the family still uses the original recipe is something they all take seriously.

Here’s a little more about the crew behind the crust:

The Story Behind the Pie

Back in the early 2000s, Steve had a simple idea: make a key lime pie that tasted like the ones he remembered from his trips to Key West. Not the overly sweet, neon-green versions you sometimes find in supermarkets, but the real thing — tart, creamy, and made the way it was meant to be. He started small, baking in a local kitchen and selling slices out of a booth at the weekend market.

• New Jersey Motor Sports

Word spread quickly. Locals loved the taste of something familiar, and visitors couldn’t get enough of the pie that felt like a mini vacation in a single bite. By 2005, Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie had its own storefront in Red Hook, Brooklyn. And now, over 20 years later, they’ve expanded to a few other locations, including spots in Uptown and Long Island, all while keeping the same recipe and values that made them special in the first place.

Why It’s Called “Authentic”

You might be wondering what makes a key lime pie “authentic.” Well, it’s not just a catchy name — it’s a promise. Steve’s pies are made with real key lime juice, not the bottled stuff you find in most grocery stores. The crust is hand-pressed and baked fresh daily, and the filling? That’s where the magic happens. It’s thick, smooth, and has just the right balance between sweet and tart.

According to the Oxford English Dictionary, something “authentic” is “made or done in the original or traditional way.” That’s exactly what Steve and his team do every day. They don’t cut corners, and they don’t change the recipe just to keep up with trends. The way Steve sees it, if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it — and when you’ve got a pie that’s been loved for over two decades, you’ve got something worth holding onto.

Where to Buy Steve’s Pies

If you’re in Brooklyn or nearby, you’re in luck — Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie is available at several locations. The main shop is at 185 Van Dyke Street in Red Hook, Brooklyn. This is your best bet if you want to grab a slice on the spot, or pick up a whole pie to take home. They’re open Friday through Sunday, with weekend hours starting at 11 a.m. and closing at 8 p.m.

For those who can’t make the trip, there are also locations in Uptown and a few spots around Long Island. Just expand the map on their website to find the nearest place to grab a pie. Whether you’re planning a weekend picnic or just need a sweet treat for the family, Steve’s got you covered.

How to Order and Ship a Pie

Can’t make it to Brooklyn? Don’t worry — you can still enjoy Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie no matter where you are. The team offers shipping for those who want a fresh pie delivered straight to their door. Whether it’s for a special occasion, a gift for a friend, or just because you’re craving something sweet, ordering couldn’t be easier.

Here’s how it works:

1. Visit the Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie website
2. Choose your pie size (they offer individual slices, 6-inch mini pies, and full 9-inch pies)
3. Select your shipping preference (they ship nationwide with cold packs to keep everything fresh)
4. Place your order and wait for the pie to arrive at your doorstep

And here’s the best part: no matter where you are, you’re getting the same quality and taste that Brooklyn locals rave about. Amanda Hesser from the New York Times even called it one of the best key lime pies outside the Mason-Dixon line — and we all know that’s saying something.

Steve’s Pie vs. The Rest

There are a lot of key lime pies out there — but not all of them are created equal. Here’s what sets Steve’s apart:

• Real key lime juice: No artificial flavors or bottled mixes — just the real thing.
• Handmade crust: Each crust is made fresh daily, giving it a texture that’s crisp but never too crunchy.
• Thick, creamy filling: Steve’s filling is rich and silky, with just the right amount of tartness to balance the sweetness.
• Family-owned and operated: When you buy a pie from Steve’s, you’re supporting a real family business that cares about what they do.

So if you’ve ever had a key lime pie that tasted like it was made in a lab, you’ll know the difference when you try Steve’s. It’s not just about flavor — it’s about experience, tradition, and the kind of care that comes from making something by hand, the way it was always meant to be made.

FAQ Section

Where is Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie located?

The main location is at 185 Van Dyke Street in Red Hook, Brooklyn. There are also other spots in Uptown and Long Island. You can use their map to find the nearest location to you.

Can I order a pie online and have it shipped?

Yes, you absolutely can! Steve’s offers shipping for all their pies, making it easy to enjoy a fresh slice no matter where you are in the country. Just place your order online, and the pie will arrive chilled and ready to enjoy.

What makes Steve’s pie “authentic”?

It’s all in the ingredients and the process. Steve’s pies are made with real key lime juice, a handmade crust, and the original recipe that’s been used since day one. That’s what makes it authentic — and what makes it taste like the real thing.

If you're looking for something sweet, satisfying, and made with love, Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie is the way to go. Whether you're grabbing one in person or having it shipped, you're getting a piece of something special — a pie that’s been made with the same care and passion for over 20 years.

Want to learn more about the history of key lime pie and how Steve’s version compares to others? Check out our full blog post on the evolution of this classic dessert. Or, if you’re curious about how to store your pie once it arrives, we’ve got a handy guide for that too. Either way, there’s a lot to love about Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie — and we’re just getting started.

Learn more about Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie on our site, and don’t forget to share your favorite pie moments with us in the comments below. After all, every bite tells a story — and we’d love to hear yours.